CD vs. Treasury Bill Calculator
State and local income tax exempts Treasury interest. In a high-tax state that exemption can beat a bigger headline CD rate.
Putting a number on the state-tax exemption
State and local income tax exempts Treasury interest; CD interest gets no such relief. In Texas or Florida that sentence buys you nothing. In a 9%-bracket state it is worth nine cents out of every interest dollar — enough for a 4.15% T-bill to beat a 4.40% CD for a great many savers. The calculator runs this arithmetic on your actual brackets, which is the only honest way to answer the question.
One useful shortcut: the CD’s after-tax-equivalent Treasury yield is APY × (1 − fed − state) ÷ (1 − fed). Where the T-bill on offer yields more than that, the Treasury wins, headline rates notwithstanding.
Liquidity works differently, not better or worse
Breaking a CD costs a fixed, known number of months of interest. Selling a T-bill early costs whatever the market says on the day — you can finish ahead if rates fell, or behind if they rose. One is an insurance policy with a stated premium; the other is an open position. Match that to your temperament as much as to your math.